Supreme Court Rules on Notices to Appear: Niz-Chavez v. Garland
On April 29, 2021, the U.S. Supreme Court handed a victory to an immigrant facing deportation in Niz-Chavez v. Garland. The Court faulted the federal government for improperly notifying a long-term immigrant about his removal hearing. At the time, many saw the decision as new hope for thousands of people in removal proceedings.
The 2021 Ruling & What It Meant for Immigrants Facing Deportation
The Supreme Court overturned a lower-court decision that had kept a long-term immigrant from Guatemala, Agusto Niz-Chavez, from requesting cancellation of removal based on the number of years he had lived in the country.
The decision of the justices turned on a technical issue. The Court held that the immigration law requires the concerned authorities to include all relevant details for a notice to appear (NTA) in court in a single document instead of providing the same information through multiple notices or documents. An NTA is deficient if relevant information, such as the date and time of a removal hearing, is not included in a single notice. This mattered because, under the law’s “stop-time rule,” the clock for the years of presence needed for cancellation of removal stops only when a proper notice is served.
The Court’s reasoning
Conservative Justice Neil Gorsuch wrote in the ruling that “In this case, the law’s terms ensure that, when the federal government seeks a procedural advantage against an individual, it will at least supply him with a single and reasonably comprehensive statement of the nature of the proceedings against him.”
At the time, the ruling was expected to affect many pending cases by giving some immigrants a stronger chance to show that they qualify for cancellation of removal.
Where things stand now
Niz-Chavez remains good law, and it still helps people whose only notice to appear lacked a date and time. But the Supreme Court limited its reach on June 14, 2024, in Campos-Chaves v. Garland. By a 5–4 vote, the Court held that a person who was later sent a notice of hearing with the date and time cannot reopen an in absentia (missed-hearing) removal order just because the original NTA was incomplete.
Whether a notice defect helps in your case depends on the facts, including what notices you received and whether you attended. If you have a removal case, call our office so we can review your paperwork. Sources: Campos-Chaves v. Garland, 602 U.S. 447 (2024).
Call our office today at (818) 900-5707 to speak with an experienced immigration attorney. We can review your situation, explain your options, and help you build a strong case.
ATTORNEY ADVERTISING. The information on this Site is for general informational purposes only, does not constitute legal advice, and does not create an attorney–client relationship. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.






